Masky x Reader Part One - Do You Think I'm Manly?

"DAMN IT, someone needs to put a leash on that fucker!’’ You slammed the front door behind you. This caused Jeff, Ben, Masky, Hoodie, and Slenderman to jump in surprise on the couch... they all stared for a moment before a grouchy voice broke the silence. "Shark week, huh?’’ Ben said, smirking.

Slenderman facepalmed, knowing that Ben was trying to pick a fight with you.

"YOU LITTLE PRICK!" You charged at Ben, making him lunge off the couch. "IT WAS A JOKE... (Y/N)... PLEASE NUUUUUUUUUUUU S-STOP!!!’’

You chased him around the couch before Ben was exhausted, out of breath and couldn’t run anymore. He had his hands on his knees, eyes closed as he exhaled heavily.

"HAH- like I would waste my energy on you Ben.’’ You sighed, leaning against the wall.

"umm (Y/N), what’s the matter?’’ you heard someone say from the scared group of men staring at you from behind the couch.

It was your boyfriend, Masky. "o-oh, nothing just had the rake play hid and seek with my ass!’’ you flared your arms in the air.

"*sigh* not surprised’’ Jeff said visibly looking at your curves. You felt your cheeks burned. "w-what?! what is that suppose to mean’’ you stuttered. "Na, nothing. Just meaning you're attractive and any male would chase you like an animal.’’ That got Masky’s attrition real quick. Masky faced Jeff, making Jeff have an immediate fearful reaction. Masky's whole body spoke it all, it said: "drop dead idiot she’s my woman!"

Masky was a pretty shy and timid guy, 90% of the time. That’s why you liked him so much. You two have been dating for 3…2 years? It’s been a long time, so you felt strong feelings for him and you felt like he loved you too.

However, when Jeff said that, you know he'd be pissed. Jeff moved closer to Masky in a cocky manner. "Relax mask boy!’" Jeff laid his white, leathery hand your boyfriends shoulder. Masky brushed Jeff's hand off and shoved Jeff back some. They both got into each other's faces like they both were going to kill another. Slenderman used his tendrils to pull the heated males apart. "Masky chill.." You put your hands against his chest, forcing him to move back.

"Jeff…shut the fuck up.’’ You tilted your head back to view his forever open eyes and eerie smile. He sighed in defeat, walking over to the fuming boyfriend. "Hey Masky, since you think you’re so manly, why don’t you go upstairs with (Y/N) and treat her like a woman...Ya know...before I do.’’ Jeff smirked walking towards the kitchen.
"or I could just show you how I can scoop out your heart and give it to jack.’’ (Who is sitting on the railing of the stairs, tilting his head)

Your face grew redder with anger as this conversation progressed. "whatever man.’’ Jeff said disappearing into the kitchen.

The boys chilled after the ordeal and began to watch the TV, all but one…Masky. He was still bothered by what Jeff said. He tilted his head down to view your angered expression. You looked up at him, softening your expression. He seemed sad, almost. 

Pulling you aside from the group, he led you to the stairs, slowing lifting his hand to rub the back of his head. 

 "(Y/N) do you think I’m manl-...’’ his voice trailed off from a whisper to silence. You sort of got his thoughts. He didn't feel physically threatened by Jeff, he could handle him. However, he felt intimidated with what he said. "Before I do."
...'was he serious? Would she prefer someone brash...?' Masky's thoughts raced, fear of losing you rushing through his chest. 

You grabbed his hand and comforted him with your smile. He chuckled and lifted up his mask to kiss you. His lips lifted from yours, moving to your ear. "Do you want me to show you?.’’ He whispered in your ear making you blush like a motherfucker.

 ‘’uhh-umm—sure...’’ You smile softly to him, looking away shyly. He leaned into you to kiss you once more. "then tonight I shall.’’